You Are Not Stuck, You Are Comfortable

A rubber band in a drawer is just a loop of rubber. It only does anything when it is stretched, and the same is true of the person holding it.

Pick up a rubber band and look at it sitting in your hand. It is a loop of rubber. It does nothing. It holds nothing together, it launches nothing, it has no purpose at all until somebody stretches it.

That is the whole Law, and it is the only one of the fifteen where the object does the explaining for you.

The Law of the Rubber Band says growth stops when you lose the tension between where you are and where you could be. Notice what that does not say. It does not say growth stops when you fail. It does not say growth stops when things get hard. Failure and hardship keep plenty of people growing. What stops growth is the gap closing, and the gap can close two ways. You can rise to meet it, which is the good version. Or you can quietly lower it to meet you, which is the common one, and which feels like nothing at all while it is happening.

That is why this Law is sneaky. Every other Law on this list warns you about something that hurts. This one warns you about something that feels fine. Comfortable is a pleasant, well-earned, entirely reasonable state, and it is also the exact condition in which nothing further happens.

Comfortable Is Not the Same as Content

I want to separate two things that get treated as one, because the difference matters and people use the confusion to stay put.

Content is a good state. It means you have looked at your life, and you want it, and you are not chasing something to fill a hole. Content people can still be stretched. In fact they usually stretch better, because they are not doing it out of panic.

Comfortable is different. Comfortable is the absence of demand. Nothing in your week asks anything of you that you cannot already do. That is not peace, it is neutral, and neutral is where capability starts quietly draining out of a person without anybody noticing, least of all them.

The test is not whether you are happy. Plenty of people are happy and stalled and that is a real option, and if you choose it on purpose I have nothing to say about it. The test is whether anything you do in a normal month requires something from you that you do not yet have.

If the honest answer is no, the band is in the drawer.

The Good Man Doing Beautifully a Thing That Had Stopped Asking Anything

I worked with a fellow who could take a three-hour walk through the building and come back with a complete picture of it in his head. He was excellent. Nobody was better at what he did, and he did it with a kind of quiet craftsmanship you do not see much anymore.

He also had not been asked a hard question in years.

That is the part I keep coming back to. Nothing was wrong. He was not coasting, he was not lazy, he was doing genuinely good work. But the job had stopped requiring anything he did not already have, and it had been that way long enough that the change was invisible from inside it. He was performing at the top of a range that had quietly stopped expanding.

I am not telling that story to criticize him. I am telling it because it is the most common version of this Law and it looks nothing like failure. It looks like a good man, doing a thing beautifully, in a role that no longer asks.

What This Looks Like When You Get It Wrong

It looks like a very good year that is identical to the year before it.

It looks like saying no to things automatically, with a reason that sounds solid, when the actual reason is that you have not been uncomfortable in a while and would prefer to keep it that way.

It looks like your best stories being old. If everything interesting you can tell about yourself happened more than five years ago, that is worth sitting with, because the stories stop when the stretch does.

And it looks like a slow revision of what you want. This is the one that gets people. You do not abandon the ambition, you just adjust it downward a little each year, in reasonable increments, each one defensible on its own, until at 55 you are describing as unrealistic a thing you were planning at 40. Nobody talked you out of it. The gap closed from the top.

Too Much Tension Snaps It

Now let me be honest about the other end, because the metaphor cuts both ways and half the advice out there ignores it.

Stretch a rubber band far enough and it breaks. It does not warn you. And a person under permanent, maximum tension is not growing either, they are grinding, and grinding produces the same flat outcome from a completely different direction.

So this is not a Law about doing more. It is about maintaining tension, which is a specific amount, and the amount is: enough that you are reaching, not so much that you are failing at everything at once.

One thing at a time. That is usually the right dose. One area of your life that is asking more of you than you can currently deliver, while the rest of it stays stable enough to hold you up. Two is possible for a stretch. Three is how people end up burned out and convinced they are not capable, when the truth is they were badly loaded, not badly built.

One Notch, Not a Leap

The practical version of this Law is smaller than people expect, and that is good news.

You do not need to quit and start over. Dramatic moves are usually a sign that somebody let the tension go to zero for ten years and is now trying to make it up in one weekend.

You need one notch. One thing on the calendar that you do not fully know how to do yet. Volunteer for the presentation instead of the handout. Take the account nobody wants. Say yes to the class where you will be the least experienced person in the room. Ask for the assignment that is half a size too big.

One notch is enough because tension compounds. The thing that is a stretch this quarter is your baseline next year, and the notch after that one starts from higher ground. That is the entire mechanism, and it never requires a leap.

Why a Mentor Is Tension You Can Schedule

Here is the practical connection, and it is the reason this Law and mentorship belong together.

Tension does not arrive on its own once you are competent. Early in a career it does, because everything is new and the job supplies all the stretch you can handle. Then you get good, and the supply stops, and nobody tells you it stopped.

After that, tension has to be added deliberately, and the cheapest reliable source of it is a person who is further along than you.

Sit with somebody two steps ahead and the gap reopens on its own. Not because they lecture you. Because you hear how they think about a problem you thought you had figured out, and you realize there is a whole level to it you had not considered. That is the band being stretched, and it happens in the first twenty minutes without anybody trying.

That is also the honest answer to whether this is worth what it costs. You are not paying for advice, which is free and everywhere. You are paying for the return of a gap you lost, and for somebody who will keep pointing at it when you get comfortable again.

Start here:

One Thing to Do This Week

Say yes to one thing you are not fully qualified for.

Not a leap. One notch. The presentation instead of the slides. The customer call instead of the email. The class where you will be the least experienced person in the room.

Then notice the feeling you get right after you commit, that slightly sick "what did I just do" feeling.

That feeling is the band under tension. You have not felt it in a while, and it is the most reliable evidence there is that something is about to happen.

About the author

Jay Olivo spent forty years in industry, most of it on a plant floor, before he ever called himself a coach. He is a John Maxwell Certified Executive Coach, a DISC consultant and a CPMM, and he wrote Leadership Between the Lines and built the LBL-10 workshop.

He runs John's 15 Laws Mastermind through Leadership TeamBuilder, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, EIN 82-2541896. The Wednesday evening workshop is free and nothing is sold in it.

Read Jay's full story →

Put One Law Into Practice, With People Who Will Notice

John's 15 Laws Mastermind is a small group built on honest reflection, guided discussion and real accountability — eight weeks, six to eight people, using Maxwell's framework for intentional growth. Or start with the free Wednesday workshop; nothing is sold in it.

Save My Seat Wednesday